Siegner v Shmihelsky
Last updated: August 9, 2026
Order
Decision in favor of
Landlord
Dispute Categories
Notices Sent
Subsections of RTA Quoted
Agree with the ruling?
PDF provided by the Ontario LTB Order Catalogue
Citation: Siegner v Shmihelsky, LTB-L-013103-25
File Number: LTB-L-013103-25
Timeline
Hearing Date
May 2026
Order Date
May 19, 2026
Tenancy End Date
Aug 2026
Decision
The Landlord's application to terminate the tenancy for renovations is granted. The termination date is set for August 31, 2026, to allow the Tenant time to find alternative housing.
Reason for Eviction Relief
The Tenant requested additional time to find alternative housing and resources due to personal health and financial challenges.
Dispute
The Landlord applied to terminate the tenancy for extensive renovations requiring a building permit and vacant possession. The Tenant requested time to vacate due to personal circumstances.
Determinations
- The Landlord has proven in good faith the intent to perform extensive renovations requiring a building permit and vacant possession.
- The Tenant is granted relief from eviction until August 31, 2026.
Landlord's Arguments
Actions and Evidence
The Landlord demonstrated good faith intent to renovate, including gutting the bathroom, replacing the heating system, and electrical panel upgrades, supported by building permits.
Considerations
Tenant's Arguments
Actions and Evidence
The Tenant noted difficulties in finding new housing due to health conditions and lack of family support.
Considerations
Similar Cases
Click to switch between order outcomes
Toronto Community Housing Corporation v Palacios
The LTB found that an unauthorized occupant committed illegal acts and impaired safety at the residential complex, but granted the Tenant conditional relief from eviction.
Saickley Enterprises Ltd. v Holst
The LTB terminated the tenancy and ordered eviction based on an unfulfilled agreement to terminate, requiring the tenant to pay the filing fee.
Singh and Thind Holding Inc. v Boyd
The LTB denied a tenant's review request of a consent termination order, finding no serious error or valid grounds to overturn the agreement despite changed financial circumstances.
Maebrook Rideau Inc. v Hiyadi
The Landlord was granted an order terminating the tenancy and requiring the Tenant to pay rent arrears following the Tenant's departure from the unit.
Toronto Community Housing Corporation v Palacios
The LTB found that an unauthorized occupant committed illegal acts and impaired safety at the residential complex, but granted the Tenant conditional relief from eviction.
Saickley Enterprises Ltd. v Holst
The LTB terminated the tenancy and ordered eviction based on an unfulfilled agreement to terminate, requiring the tenant to pay the filing fee.
Singh and Thind Holding Inc. v Boyd
The LTB denied a tenant's review request of a consent termination order, finding no serious error or valid grounds to overturn the agreement despite changed financial circumstances.
Maebrook Rideau Inc. v Hiyadi
The Landlord was granted an order terminating the tenancy and requiring the Tenant to pay rent arrears following the Tenant's departure from the unit.
Toronto Community Housing Corporation v Palacios
The LTB found that an unauthorized occupant committed illegal acts and impaired safety at the residential complex, but granted the Tenant conditional relief from eviction.
Saickley Enterprises Ltd. v Holst
The LTB terminated the tenancy and ordered eviction based on an unfulfilled agreement to terminate, requiring the tenant to pay the filing fee.
Singh and Thind Holding Inc. v Boyd
The LTB denied a tenant's review request of a consent termination order, finding no serious error or valid grounds to overturn the agreement despite changed financial circumstances.
Maebrook Rideau Inc. v Hiyadi
The Landlord was granted an order terminating the tenancy and requiring the Tenant to pay rent arrears following the Tenant's departure from the unit.
Toronto Community Housing Corporation v Palacios
The LTB found that an unauthorized occupant committed illegal acts and impaired safety at the residential complex, but granted the Tenant conditional relief from eviction.
Saickley Enterprises Ltd. v Holst
The LTB terminated the tenancy and ordered eviction based on an unfulfilled agreement to terminate, requiring the tenant to pay the filing fee.
Singh and Thind Holding Inc. v Boyd
The LTB denied a tenant's review request of a consent termination order, finding no serious error or valid grounds to overturn the agreement despite changed financial circumstances.
Maebrook Rideau Inc. v Hiyadi
The Landlord was granted an order terminating the tenancy and requiring the Tenant to pay rent arrears following the Tenant's departure from the unit.
Maebrook Rideau Inc. v Hiyadi
The Landlord was granted an order terminating the tenancy and requiring the Tenant to pay rent arrears and application fees, offset by the rent deposit and interest.
R*** Hotel and Resorts Inc. v Lawrence
The LTB terminated the tenancy and ordered eviction without a hearing based on a signed agreement to terminate.
Singh and Thind Holding Inc. v Boyd
The LTB dismissed a tenant's review request seeking to set aside a consent termination order, upholding the agreement and noting the tenant's breach of hearing recording prohibitions.
Singh and Thind Holding Inc. v Boyd
The LTB dismissed a tenant's review request seeking to set aside a consent termination order, finding no procedural unfairness or grounds to overturn the valid agreement.
Latest Insights from Our Blog
Stay informed with expert analysis on rental law, tenant rights, and LTB decisions
Unauthorized Occupants, Assignments, and Subletting: Understanding Ontario's Complex Tenancy Transfer Rules
A comprehensive analysis of LTB cases reveals the strict rules governing tenant assignments and subletting, the severe consequences of unauthorized occupancy, and the substantial financial penalties that follow. Learn when transfers are legal and how to protect your rights.
Top Tenant Mistakes in LTB Applications (And How to Avoid Them)
Learn from real LTB cases why tenant applications fail. Discover the most common mistakes that lead to dismissed applications and practical strategies to strengthen your case and protect your rights as a tenant.
How to Enforce an LTB Eviction Order in Ontario: Sheriff Process, Stays, and Lockout Day
Won at the LTB but the tenant won't leave? Learn how Ontario landlords enforce eviction orders through the Sheriff, what happens on lockout day, daily compensation rules, and how tenant stays can delay enforcement.
Need Legal Help? We've Got You Covered
Whether you need to find qualified legal professionals or post your specific legal needs to get competitive quotes, our platform connects you with the right help.
Find Legal Professionals
Browse our directory of verified paralegals and lawyers specializing in Ontario rental law and LTB matters.
Browse ProfessionalsPost Your Legal Needs
Describe your legal situation and receive competitive quotes from qualified professionals in our marketplace.
Post a BountyJoin thousands of Ontarians who have found legal help through our platform